| Tournament | Round | Brenda Thurgar | Paula Messer |
| 08.06.1998 Victorian Championships (VIC) | 7 | 386 | 347 |
| 14.06.1999 Victorian Championships (VIC) | 5 | 299 | 370 |
| 06.08.2000 Knox (VIC) | 5 | 282 | 396 |
| 03.12.2000 McKinnon (VIC) | 3 | 569 | 323 |
| 25.02.2001 Camberwell (VIC) | 3 | 439 | 310 |
| 10.06.2002 Victorian Championships (VIC) | 3 | 391 | 382 |
| 13.04.2003 Western Suburbs (VIC) | 5 | 367 | 338 |
| 27.07.2003 Bentleigh (VIC) | 6 | 398 | 467 |
| 28.09.2003 Essendon (VIC) | 2 | 278 | 422 |
| 01.05.2005 Mayday (VIC) | 7 | 370 | 390 |
| 20.08.2005 Bentleigh (VIC) | 2 | 405 | 365 |
| 27.11.2005 McKinnon (VIC) | 5 | 346 | 319 |
| 02.04.2006 Langwarrin (VIC) | 3 | 316 | 438 |
| 02.12.2007 Bentleigh (VIC) | 4 | 377 | 375 |
| 21.03.2010 Langwarrin (VIC) | 5 | 312 | 452 |
| Head-to-head after 15 games | 8 | 7 | |
| Average score | 369 | 379.6 | |
| Spread: | -159 | 159 | |