| Tournament | Round | Carleen Agar | Dorothy Horton |
| 14.03.1999 Ulverstone (TAS) | 3 | 313 | 403 |
| 14.03.1999 Ulverstone (TAS) | 12 | 338 | 343 |
| 13.06.1999 Round Robin (TAS) | 2 | 402 | 340 |
| 13.06.1999 Round Robin (TAS) | 11 | 415 | 390 |
| 31.10.1999 Tasmanian Championships (TAS) | 9 | 318 | 393 |
| 29.10.2000 Hobart October (TAS) | 8 | 301 | 433 |
| 27.10.2001 Tasmanian Championships (TAS) | 7 | 399 | 407 |
| 20.04.2002 Beaumaris (TAS) | 9 | 250 | 444 |
| 09.02.2003 Ulverstone (TAS) | 12 | 400 | 374 |
| 25.01.2004 Ulverstone (TAS) | 3 | 336 | 423 |
| 14.03.2004 Launceston (TAS) | 2 | 358 | 332 |
| 23.01.2005 Ulverstone (TAS) | 8 | 359 | 378 |
| 30.10.2005 Tasmanian Championships (TAS) | 7 | 323 | 340 |
| 27.08.2006 Exeter Round Robin (TAS) | 1 | 422 | 336 |
| 27.08.2006 Exeter Round Robin (TAS) | 8 | 226 | 405 |
| 29.10.2006 Tasmanian Championships (TAS) | 7 | 357 | 314 |
| Head-to-head after 16 games | 6 | 10 | |
| Average score | 344.81 | 378.43 | |
| Spread: | -538 | 538 | |