| Tournament | Round | Carmel Doney | Jimmy Scarff |
| 30.09.2001 Essendon (VIC) | 1 | 302 | 434 |
| 29.01.2005 Ballarat (VIC) | 3 | 401 | 463 |
| 20.02.2005 Nunawading Matchplay Qualifier (VIC) | 3 | 301 | 394 |
| 28.12.2008 Decathon (VIC) | 8 | 324 | 473 |
| 07.12.2014 FRANKSTON NORTH 2 (VIC) | 1 | 344 | 367 |
| Head-to-head after 5 games | 0 | 5 | |
| Average score | 334.4 | 426.2 | |
| Spread: | -459 | 459 | |