| Tournament | Round | Jimmy Scarff | Val Hardiman |
| 27.09.1998 Essendon (VIC) | 1 | 370 | 311 |
| 09.11.2003 Geelong (VIC) | 5 | 351 | 367 |
| 13.02.2005 Camberwell (VIC) | 6 | 452 | 404 |
| 22.08.2010 Jim Warmington (VIC) | 1 | 343 | 423 |
| Head-to-head after 4 games | 2 | 2 | |
| Average score | 379 | 376.25 | |
| Spread: | 11 | -11 | |