| Tournament | Round | John Holgate | Arnold Appelhof |
| 05.10.2015 NSW Championships (NSW) | 12 | 403 | 350 |
| 02.10.2017 NSW CHAMPS (NSW) | 4 | 376 | 322 |
| 02.10.2017 NSW CHAMPS (NSW) | 13 | 540 | 335 |
| 26.01.2018 Australia Day Open (NSW) | 2 | 440 | 402 |
| 25.07.2020 WinterMasters (NSW) | 1 | 434 | 331 |
| 25.07.2020 WinterMasters (NSW) | 14 | 357 | 394 |
| 30.01.2022 City of Sydney Masters (NSW) | 1 | 422 | 399 |
| 02.07.2022 NO FRILLS 3 (NSW) | 2 | 487 | 395 |
| 03.10.2022 2022 NSW CHAMPIONSHIP (NSW) | 9 | 430 | 330 |
| 03.10.2022 2022 NSW CHAMPIONSHIP (NSW) | 13 | 351 | 445 |
| 03.11.2022 Seniors Championship (NSW) | 5 | 387 | 358 |
| 16.07.2023 2023 Winter Masters (NSW) | 1 | 473 | 321 |
| 16.07.2023 2023 Winter Masters (NSW) | 16 | 444 | 326 |
| 08.06.2024 2024 Victorian Championship (VIC) | 11 | 372 | 412 |
| 07.10.2024 NSW CHAMPIONSHIP 2024 (NSW) | 1 | 490 | 362 |
| Head-to-head after 15 games | 12 | 3 | |
| Average score | 427.06 | 365.46 | |
| Spread: | 924 | -924 | |