| Tournament | Round | Julian Mckail | Val Hardiman |
| 01.12.2002 McKinnon (VIC) | 5 | 382 | 446 |
| 15.02.2004 Camberwell (VIC) | 2 | 406 | 339 |
| 24.07.2005 Midwinter (VIC) | 2 | 459 | 309 |
| 23.07.2006 Midwinter (VIC) | 6 | 467 | 322 |
| 17.02.2008 Camberwell (VIC) | 5 | 385 | 430 |
| 22.08.2010 Jim Warmington (VIC) | 5 | 395 | 391 |
| 20.02.2011 Camberwell (VIC) | 4 | 452 | 349 |
| 25.09.2011 Essendon (VIC) | 3 | 463 | 389 |
| 01.02.2015 CAMBERWELL (VIC) | 1 | 496 | 250 |
| Head-to-head after 9 games | 7 | 2 | |
| Average score | 433.88 | 358.33 | |
| Spread: | 680 | -680 | |