| Tournament | Round | Nanette Reynolds | Donna MacDonald |
| 04.04.1998 Hassall Grove (NSW) | 3 | 402 | 289 |
| 26.03.2001 Wyong (NSW) | 4 | 346 | 340 |
| 09.09.2001 Baulkham Hills Open (NSW) | 5 | 313 | 375 |
| 13.11.2004 Sydney (NSW) | 8 | 312 | 372 |
| 20.03.2005 Wyong (NSW) | 6 | 311 | 407 |
| 14.08.2005 Oatlands (NSW) | 6 | 314 | 403 |
| 03.12.2005 Turramurra (NSW) | 5 | 332 | 451 |
| 31.08.2008 Oatlands (NSW) | 1 | 342 | 386 |
| 01.03.2009 Balmain BUGS (NSW) | 1 | 357 | 357 |
| 16.01.2011 Yearly Nearly Early (NSW) | 6 | 304 | 393 |
| 04.03.2012 Balmain BUGS (NSW) | 1 | 363 | 369 |
| 25.11.2012 CENTRAL COAST C'SHIP 2 DAY (NSW) | 12 | 327 | 390 |
| 03.03.2013 Balmain BUGS (NSW) | 1 | 342 | 433 |
| 01.06.2013 CENTRAL COAST (NSW) | 2 | 353 | 317 |
| 28.06.2014 REVESBY CLUB (NSW) | 8 | 315 | 458 |
| 05.12.2015 Sutherland Shire (NSW) | 2 | 413 | 389 |
| 10.04.2016 Lake Macquarie (NSW) | 4 | 366 | 348 |
| 09.04.2017 Lake Macquarie (NSW) | 7 | 404 | 371 |
| 16.07.2017 Winter Challenge (NSW) | 5 | 262 | 404 |
| 20.08.2017 Baulkham Hills (NSW) | 2 | 300 | 318 |
| 05.05.2018 Lake Macquarie (NSW) | 6 | 321 | 403 |
| Head-to-head after 21 games | 6.5 | 14.5 | |
| Average score | 338.04 | 379.66 | |
| Spread: | -874 | 874 | |