| Tournament | Round | Paula Messer | Cath Catmull |
| 08.02.1998 Camberwell (VIC) | 3 | 370 | 370 |
| 08.06.1998 Victorian Championships (VIC) | 8 | 349 | 431 |
| 19.03.2000 Prahran (VIC) | 6 | 429 | 319 |
| 21.01.2001 Aestival (VIC) | 6 | 412 | 328 |
| 27.11.2005 McKinnon (VIC) | 3 | 341 | 328 |
| Head-to-head after 5 games | 3.5 | 1.5 | |
| Average score | 380.2 | 355.2 | |
| Spread: | 125 | -125 | |