| Tournament | Round | Penny Wells | Alan Mathews |
| 19.09.2009 CAMPBELL TOWN (TAS) | 7 | 374 | 384 |
| 12.12.2009 Ross Christmas 2009 (TAS) | 7 | 410 | 336 |
| 18.09.2010 Moonah Open (TAS) | 2 | 312 | 422 |
| 11.12.2010 Ross Xmas 2010 (TAS) | 2 | 307 | 394 |
| 19.03.2011 Kingston Saturday (TAS) | 2 | 328 | 353 |
| 20.03.2011 Kingston Sunday (TAS) | 5 | 335 | 347 |
| 21.08.2011 Campbell Town (TAS) | 7 | 333 | 410 |
| 17.03.2012 Kingston Saturday (TAS) | 7 | 308 | 522 |
| 18.03.2012 Kingston Sunday (TAS) | 6 | 410 | 356 |
| 22.09.2012 Eastern Sat (TAS) | 8 | 425 | 315 |
| 15.09.2013 EASTERN SHORE Sunday (TAS) | 5 | 340 | 315 |
| Head-to-head after 11 games | 4 | 7 | |
| Average score | 352.9 | 377.63 | |