| Tournament | Round | Peter Shaw | Nanette Reynolds |
| 04.04.1998 Hassall Grove (NSW) | 7 | 430 | 419 |
| 30.08.1998 Baulkham Hills (NSW) | 4 | 315 | 383 |
| 05.09.1999 Baulkham Hills Open (NSW) | 4 | 381 | 350 |
| 14.02.2004 Matchplay Qualifier (NSW) | 1 | 402 | 263 |
| 27.02.2016 Matchplay Qualifier (NSW) | 4 | 338 | 332 |
| 16.10.2016 Spring Marathon (NSW) | 2 | 429 | 410 |
| Head-to-head after 6 games | 5 | 1 | |
| Average score | 382.5 | 359.5 | |
| Spread: | 138 | -138 | |