| Tournament | Round | Peter Shaw | Robin Duncan |
| 01.03.1998 Balmain (NSW) | 2 | 378 | 449 |
| 15.03.1998 Sutherland (NSW) | 3 | 405 | 327 |
| 12.07.1998 Chatswood (NSW) | 3 | 355 | 444 |
| 12.12.1998 North Shore (NSW) | 5 | 293 | 466 |
| 13.02.1999 Wollongong (NSW) | 8 | 434 | 267 |
| 05.03.2000 Balmain Bugs (NSW) | 5 | 252 | 424 |
| 07.07.2000 Chatswood (NSW) | 3 | 391 | 402 |
| 21.01.2001 Baulkham Hills Kick-off (NSW) | 4 | 353 | 379 |
| 10.11.2001 Sydney (NSW) | 5 | 285 | 379 |
| 09.11.2002 Sydney (NSW) | 7 | 401 | 387 |
| 03.07.2004 Chatswood (NSW) | 3 | 458 | 384 |
| 02.07.2005 Chatswood (NSW) | 2 | 339 | 453 |
| 05.03.2006 Balmain BUGS (NSW) | 7 | 306 | 452 |
| 28.10.2006 Sydney (NSW) | 2 | 425 | 405 |
| 02.03.2008 Balmain BUGS (NSW) | 6 | 393 | 350 |
| 03.01.2009 Janboree (NSW) | 3 | 358 | 335 |
| 10.01.2010 Yearly Nearly Early (NSW) | 3 | 450 | 398 |
| 07.03.2010 Balmain BUGS (NSW) | 1 | 303 | 425 |
| Head-to-head after 18 games | 8 | 10 | |
| Average score | 365.5 | 395.88 | |
| Spread: | -547 | 547 | |