| Tournament | Round | Susan MacGillivray | Donna MacDonald |
| 20.07.2003 Winter Masters (NSW) | 10 | 370 | 359 |
| 20.07.2003 Winter Masters (NSW) | 19 | 387 | 336 |
| 09.11.2003 Sydney (NSW) | 1 | 426 | 393 |
| 24.07.2005 Winter Masters (NSW) | 9 | 399 | 336 |
| 24.07.2005 Winter Masters (NSW) | 13 | 302 | 405 |
| 22.07.2007 Winter Masters (NSW) | 4 | 389 | 390 |
| 22.07.2007 Winter Masters (NSW) | 16 | 409 | 332 |
| 05.01.2008 Janboree (NSW) | 8 | 381 | 410 |
| 15.07.2018 Winter Challenge (NSW) | 12 | 352 | 402 |
| Head-to-head after 9 games | 5 | 4 | |
| Average score | 379.44 | 373.66 | |
| Spread: | 52 | -52 | |