| Tournament | Round | Susan Macgillivray | Nanette Reynolds |
| 05.10.1998 New South Wales Championships (NSW) | 12 | 355 | 382 |
| 04.10.1999 New South Wales Championships (NSW) | 9 | 351 | 427 |
| 18.08.2001 Revesby (NSW) | 3 | 361 | 363 |
| 01.10.2001 New South Wales Championships (NSW) | 18 | 350 | 322 |
| 15.07.2018 Winter Challenge (NSW) | 1 | 327 | 374 |
| Head-to-head after 5 games | 1 | 4 | |
| Average score | 348.8 | 373.6 | |
| Spread: | -124 | 124 | |